Did the family move,
or did the boundary?
Entirely fictional demonstration. Names, places, records, quotations and dates below are invented to show report structure. No historical claim or real client result is represented. Source IDs point to illustrative descriptions, not real archival citations.
Case: DEMO-001 · Question: Did Elias Reed leave Pine Township between 1848 and 1852?
Scope: Three total hours, documentary comparison only. No onsite research.
Prepared by: [researcher in an actual report] · Report version/date: [completed for an actual case]. These are format placeholders, not dates of research performed.
Answer at this stage
The supplied evidence is consistent with the same parcel being recorded under different county names. It does not yet establish that the two Elias Reed entries concern the same person or prove that he stayed there throughout the period.
Evidence and interpretation
| Source | What it says in this demonstration | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|
| S1 · 1848 tax list | Elias Reed; Pine Township; parcel 12; 40 acres. | A taxpayer need not be a resident. The entry does not identify his family. |
| S2 · 1852 tax list | E. Reed; Pine Township; parcel 12; 40 acres; a different county heading. | Initials and acreage alone do not prove identity or continuous ownership. |
| S3 · boundary description | The named township transferred to the new county in 1850. | A township-level account does not independently locate the particular parcel. |
Reasoning and limits
A boundary change could explain the different county headings. The matching parcel number is a useful lead, but numbering systems can change. A deed description or survey is needed to test the geographic match. The abbreviated first name is an unresolved identity issue. No inference about a spouse or parent is supported.
Search log
All entries are fictional. An actual log records the search date, source, terms, coverage, access method and extent inspected so another researcher can retrace the work.
| Source and search | Date, access and extent | Result and next action |
|---|---|---|
| S1 / S2: review supplied 1848 and 1852 tax entries for Elias Reed / E. Reed | Date: [actual search date]. Supplied-entry review only; original volumes not represented in this demonstration. | Two candidates. Compare complete legal descriptions before linking identities. |
| S4: illustrative deed index; Reed / Read; 1848–1852 | Date: [actual search date]. Index only; grantor/grantee extent not specified in this demonstration and must be recorded in an actual report. | No matching entry located. Not proof that no deed exists. Expand years and check both grantor and grantee roles. |
| S3: compare illustrative 1850 township boundary description | Date: [actual search date]. Description only; no parcel-level map or original statute inspected in this demonstration. | Possible jurisdiction explanation. Locate the parcel independently. |
Prioritized next steps
- Request the complete deed and any referenced earlier instrument. Compare the legal land description.
- Check adjacent tax years to test continuity, including spelling variants and initials.
- Use household and neighbor evidence to distinguish same-name candidates only after establishing the place.
Source register
S1, fictional: Illustrative Pine Township tax list, 1848, invented entry for Elias Reed, parcel 12. No real repository or call number.
S2, fictional: Illustrative Pine Township tax list, 1852, invented entry for E. Reed, parcel 12. No real repository or call number.
S3, fictional: Invented 1850 boundary description. No real statute or map.
S4, fictional: Illustrative deed index used for the Reed / Read search, 1848–1852. No actual repository, call number or search is represented.
In a client report, each reference would identify the actual record creator, collection, volume/page or item, repository, stable URL where available, access date and whether an original image or an index was inspected. Unavailable material would be labeled.
Work budget and quality review
Illustrative allocation: 20 minutes intake review, 85 minutes research, 60 minutes verification and report preparation, and 15 minutes reserved for clarification. Total: three hours. This is an example allocation, not completed client work. The agreed brief clarification remains included even if our internal estimate is exceeded. Any AI assistance and material handling would be documented for the actual project. Every material conclusion requires human review.